Mixed
However, if there _are_ defects, it’s quite good at finding and surfacing them prominently
jgraettinger1 on Hacker News
about 8 issues
In the thread “Code Review for Claude Code”, replying to this comment
Helped: Surfacing real defects prominently after self-review.
Got in the way: Always finds 8 issues, including weak ones when no defects exist.
… Part of the art of using the tool is recognizing this is happening, and understanding it’s scraping the bottom of its barrel. However, if there _are_ defects, it’s quite good at finding and surfacing them prominently.