No
Often, it's right but it's missing the point, in a way that will lead a reader astray
sfink on Hacker News
In the thread “Opus 4.5 is not the normal AI agent experience that I have had thus far”, replying to this comment
Got in the way: Complex analysis and code reviews often miss the point or don't apply.
… But almost every time I sit down and really think about a comment that includes any of that more complex analysis, I end up discarding it. Often, it's right but it's missing the point, in a way that will lead a reader astray. It's subtle and I really ought to dig up an example, but I'm unable to find the session I'm thinking about. …