Mixed
Codex 5.2 meanwhile stubbornly accepts the view it's a product decision but won't seem to offer it's own opinion!
extr on Hacker News
90% of the way there in 3 lines
In the thread “GPT-5.2-Codex”, replying to this comment
Helped: Claude's practical shortcuts and product opinions on ambiguous bugs.
Got in the way: Codex's stubbornness in refusing to offer its own opinion.
… Claude agrees it's more of a product behavioral opinion on whether or not to persist garbage data, and offer it's own product opinion that I probably want to keep it the way it is. Codex 5.2 meanwhile stubbornly accepts the view it's a product decision but won't seem to offer it's own opinion!