Yes
Gemini is consistently offering better code review tips. It has officially caught multiple potential bugs, even a few that reviewers might have missed, so it's definitely been additive
criley2 on Hacker News
In the thread “Gemini CLI GitHub Actions”
Helped: Better code review tips and catching potential bugs.
Got in the way: Worse observability and lack of customization instructions.
… The website Agent is definitely dumber than the vscode agent (because it has to spend 20 minutes figuring out how to build and start my monorepo apps) but on the flip side, it doesn't take up my computer and thus any value it creates is additive. We have tried out Gemini code review vs Copilot code review and Gemini is consistently offering better code review tips. It has officially caught multiple potential bugs, even a few that reviewers might have missed, so it's definitely been additive. Observability looks way worse. …