Mixed
We haven't had as much luck with reviewing general PRs where the reason for a change being good or bad could be outside the diff
ghiculescu on Hacker News
In the thread “Notes on rolling out Cursor and Claude Code”, replying to this comment
Helped: Providing specific rules files and tight scope for database migrations.
Got in the way: Reviewing general PRs where context and rules are outside the diff.
… It works particularly well for migrations because all the context is in the PR. We haven't had as much luck with reviewing general PRs where the reason for a change being good or bad could be outside the diff, and where there aren't as clearly defined rules for what should be avoided.