Mixed
Both ChatGPT and Claude generated code that either bad practice or have flaw, or just ignore instructions in my prompt to come back to bad solutions after just a few questions
max6zx on Hacker News
In the thread “Claude AI built me a React app to compare maps side by side”, replying to this comment
Helped: Vague prompts for frontend projects produced working code immediately.
Got in the way: Backend code ignored instructions, had bad practices, and lacked architecture.
… And I was so suprise that the experience was completely opposite. Both ChatGPT and Claude generated code that either bad practice or have flaw, or just ignore instructions in my prompt to come back to bad solutions after just a few questions. It also fails to apply common practices from architecture perspectives. …